The Deinstitutionalization of Western European Party Systems


Alessandro Chiaramonte is Full Professor of Political Science at the University of Florence, Italy.
Vincenzo Emanuele is Assistant Professor of Political Science at Luiss Guido Carli in Rome, Italy.


“Despite the many studies on the crises of Western European party systems over the past three decades, few are theoretically novel and even fewer are characterized by relevant empirical assessments. This groundbreaking book is indeed one of them. Chiaramonte and Emanuele offer an encompassing account of the evolution of party systems in Western Europe, an excellent discussion of the theoretical components of their deinstitutionalization, as they put it, and masterly empirical analyses of their factors.”
—José Ramón Montero, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain.

“Although a great deal of attention has been devoted to party system ‘institutionalization’ in new democracies, this book focuses on the much more momentous ‘deinstitutionalization’ of the party systems of old democracies. Evidence of this phenomenon has been accumulated in various domains, and the book provides a comprehensive and coherent multidimensional framework to analyze the crisis affecting party systems with new data, indicators, and techniques.”
—-Stefano Bartolini, European University Institute in Florence, Italy.


This book offers a systematic and far-reaching account of party system institutionalization in Western Europe. Drawing upon a wide array of data and through a comparison of 20 countries from the end of WWII to 2019 across three arenas of party competition (electoral, parliamentary, and governmental ones), the empirical analysis shows that, over the past decade, the level of institutionalization in the Western European party systems has dramatically declined compared with previous decades. Electoral, parliamentary, and – in some cases – governmental instability and unpredictability have reached record-high levels. Although the impact of the 2008 Great Recession has certainly worked as a catalyst, this process of de-institutionalization has been mainly driven by long-term factors, such as cleavage decline and the titiming of the democratic onset. Moreover, its consequences are relevant not only for the relationship between parties and voters, but also for the very quality of democracy, as party system deinstitutionalization causes a decline in the citizens’ satisfaction of the way democracy works and even an erosion of the ‘objective’ democratic standards. In a nutshell, Western Europe, once seen as the land of stability and the cradle of democracy, may have become the land of party system deinstitutionalization and incipient democratic backsliding.

Keywords: Party systems; Party Politics; Elections; Democracy; Time-series-cross-section analysis

To cite the book:

Chiaramonte, A. and Emanuele, V. (2022), The deinstitutionalization of Western European party systems, London: Palgrave Macmillan.

To buy a copy or download free-access contents click here


Clearly, there are some people to thank. First, we thank all panel chairs and discussants of the conferences where we presented some preliminary drafts of our work. Preliminary versions of book chapters were presented at the conference ‘Political parties in comparative perspective’ held at the Georgetown University and the New York University, Florence, March 22-23, 2018; at the 114th annual conference of the American Political Science Association, Boston, August 30-September 2, 2018; at the 12th ECPR General Conference, Hamburg, August 22-25, 2018; at the CISE LUISS Seminar, Rome, December 6, 2018; at the 26th International Conference of Europeanists, Carlos III University, Madrid, June 20-22, 2019; at the 115th APSA Conference, Washington DC, August 29-September 1, 2019; and at the XXXIII SISP Conference, Lecce, September 12-14, 2019. We thank Hans Noel, Paul Webb, Richard Katz, Darren Schreiber, Zac Greene, Michelangelo Vercesi, Maria Laura Sudulich, Aiko Wagner, Michal Kotnarowski, Alejandro Tirado Castro, José Rama, Andrés Santana, Piotr Zagórski, Martin Bull, Despina Alexiadou, Davide Gianluca Bianchi, Francesco Raniolo, and Alessandro Campi for their feedbacks. We also warmly thank other colleagues with whom, in different venues, we discussed some book-related topics: amongst the many, Liesbet Hooghe, Gary Marks, Fernando Casal Bértoa, Paolo Segatti, Scott Mainwaring, Sorina Soare, Nicola Martocchia Diodati, Piero Ignazi, and Leonardo Morlino.

This book was born from the discussions held at the Florentine seat of the CISE and was enriched from the constant debates with the other researchers of the CISE. We therefore wholeheartedly thank the CISE founder Roberto D’Alimonte, the CISE director Lorenzo De Sio and the CISE researchers and collaborators, including Aldo Paparo, Nicola Maggini, Davide Angelucci, Luca Carrieri, Davide Vittori, and Federico Trastulli. A special ‘thank you’ shall go to Marco Improta for his help with the collection of the governmental data, Bruno Marino for having accurately read the entire manuscript, and Palgrave’s anonymous reviewers. As usual, we bear full responsibility for the errors and the shortcomings of this work.

Vincenzo Emanuele è professore associato in Scienza Politica presso la LUISS Guido Carli di Roma. Ha conseguito il dottorato di ricerca in Scienza della Politica presso la Scuola Normale Superiore (ex SUM) di Firenze con una tesi sul processo di nazionalizzazione del voto in Europa occidentale e le sue possibili determinanti. La sua tesi ha vinto il Premio 'Enrico Melchionda' conferita alle tesi di dottorato in Scienze Politiche discusse nel triennio 2012-2014 e il Premio 'Celso Ghini' come miglior tesi di dottorato in materia elettorale del biennio 2013-2014. È membro del CISE, di ITANES (Italian National Election Studies) e del Research Network in Political Parties, Party Systems and Elections del CES (Council of European Studies). I suoi interessi di ricerca si concentrano sulle elezioni e i sistemi di partito in prospettiva comparata, con particolare riferimento ai cleavages e ai processi di nazionalizzazione e istituzionalizzazione. Ha pubblicato articoli su European Journal of Political research, Comparative Political Studies, Party Politics, South European Society and Politics, Government and Opposition, Regional and Federal Studies, Journal of Contemporary European Research, oltre che sulle principali riviste scientifiche italiane. La sua prima monografia Cleavages, institutions, and competition. Understanding vote nationalization in Western Europe (1965-2015) è edita da Rowman and Littlefield/ECPR Press (2018), mentre la seconda The deinstitutionalization of Western European party systems è edita da Palgrave Macmillan. Sulle elezioni italiane del 2018, ha curato la Special Issue di Italian Political Science ‘Who’s the winner? An analysis of the 2018 Italian general election’. Clicca qui per accedere sito internet personale. Clicca qui per accedere al profilo su IRIS.